Sunrise on the Reaping Review: Better Than the Book — and That May Have Been the Plan
There's an unwritten rule about adaptations: the book is always better. It's practically a law of physics, right up there with gravity and Lightning Lane prices only ever going up.
The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, in theaters November 20, breaks the rule. Francis Lawrence's adaptation of Suzanne Collins' 2025 prequel follows a 16-year-old Haymitch Abernathy into the 50th Hunger Games, the Second Quarter Quell, when the Capitol reaps twice as many tributes as usual. It's a really good movie, much better than the book if you ask me, and I have a theory about why.
A Movie Disguised as a Book
Ms. Collins didn't start out as a novelist. She began her career in 1991 writing children's television, with staff jobs on Nickelodeon shows like Clarissa Explains It All, and she never really stopped writing for the screen. She shares screenplay credit on the 2012 Hunger Games with Gary Ross and Billy Ray, the same Mr. Ray who wrote this one. Both Mockingjay screenplays were built from her adaptation, and she's been an executive producer on all six films.
Her prequels also have a habit of getting a movie before they get readers. Lionsgate announced the Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes film a month before that novel hit shelves, with Ms. Collins writing the treatment herself. This time, the studio announced the movie, release date and all, within hours of the book's announcement in June 2024, nine months before anyone could buy a copy.
So here's my theory: Sunrise on the Reaping was written primarily to be a movie and came out as a book first because that's how Ms. Collins works. It would explain why the book never quite clicked for me, and why the movie does.
Almost Everyone Is Great
Prequels are a casting minefield. Many of the biggest roles in Sunrise on the Reaping come with a predecessor audiences already love, and nearly everyone here clears that bar.
Joseph Zada has the hardest job, playing a teenage version of the Haymitch that Woody Harrelson made iconic, and Mr. Zada pulls it off. Whitney Peak as Lenore Dove Baird and Mckenna Grace as Maysilee Donner are just as strong beside him. On the Capitol side, Ralph Fiennes takes over Coriolanus Snow, Elle Fanning steps into Effie Trinket's heels, and Kieran Culkin inherits Caesar Flickerman's microphone. Add Glenn Close and Billy Porter, plus Maya Hawke and Kelvin Harrison Jr. as younger versions of Wiress and Beetee, and the bench is almost unfair.
With one exception, the acting is excellent from top to bottom. The exception is Jesse Plemons as Plutarch Heavensbee, the role Philip Seymour Hoffman played in Catching Fire and both Mockingjay films. It's the one performance in the movie I never bought. Blame Mr. Hoffman's shadow. His Plutarch still looms over the role, and Mr. Plemons never steps out from under it.
The Fights, the Mutts, and the Music
Mr. Lawrence (no relation to Jennifer Lawrence; more on her in a minute) has now directed five of the six Hunger Gamesmovies, and he knows his way around an arena. The fight choreography is great, and the arena sequences are better for it.
The CGI is really good, too, which matters in a franchise where the arena itself is usually trying to kill everyone. The mutts in particular are a standout.
Then there's the music. James Newton Howard has scored every film in the franchise, and this time he recorded the score at Abbey Road Studios with 96 musicians and two choirs. It sounds every bit that big, and it's really, really good.
A Reunion That Works Better on Paper
Which brings me to Ms. Lawrence and Josh Hutcherson. When word broke last December that the two were coming back, I was all for it. The book closes with Haymitch telling Katniss and Peeta about his past, and who better to play them than the people who made them famous?
In practice, it didn't land for me. It's been eleven years since Mockingjay – Part 2, and Ms. Lawrence and Mr. Hutcherson look basically nothing like they did in the original movies. That's no knock on either of them. It's just what a decade does to anybody. But a moment like this runs on recognition, and that's exactly what it's missing.
It's a great idea. It's just a better idea than it is a scene.
The Verdict
Sunrise on the Reaping is the rare adaptation that beats its book. It has a strong cast, great fight choreography, excellent effects (mutts included), and a really good score. Mr. Plemons' Plutarch and a reunion that works better on paper are the only real marks against it.
If my theory is right, Ms. Collins wrote this story for the screen all along. Either way, the screen is where it belongs, and if the book left you cold, don't let that keep you out of the theater.
The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping opens in theaters and IMAX on Friday, November 20.